
[Me in the 80's]
During both pregnancies we felt strongly about keeping gender a surprise until delivery. There are certain situations that are unique, where I think I would want to know, but so far neither of us has been moved to peek behind that curtain until the play starts.
Mostly it's because it's just really fun not to know. I love listening to people's guesses. It lights up their eyes when they find out it's a surprise and know their guess is as good as ours. I loved to see how their guesses evolved with Max and strangely became about 90% accurate towards the end of the pregnancy. By the end everyone thought it was a boy, and I even had a guy riding by in a cab in midtown lean out of the window and yell "It's a boy!"
I enjoy carrying, listening to and bonding with the baby without any expectations about gender to influence that. It's so rare in life that we connect with people without already knowing a bunch of superficial details about them that in the grand scheme of things aren't important.
It also gives me 9 months to outgrow the inevitable "preference" and keep my heart open to this new person. In both pregnancies in spite of my intellectual effort to stay neutral, in my heart lived a preference. In both pregnancies my momtuition about what I was carrying has matched that gut preference, but there is always a chance that even momtuition can be off.
There is also this weird superstitious, protective part. There are so many expectations we face as a result of our gender and part of me likes to protect the baby from having to "perform" before the debut. Even if only for 9 months of his or her life.

All that said since, barring various miracles this will be our last child, in the beginning I felt a strong preference for a girl. I would love to have the chance to raise a girl and not having a girl means saying goodbye in a semi permanent way to my own girlhood. It means not being able to coach a little lady through the tougher things like adolescence, dating and career decisions and maybe helping her avoid at least a couple of the mistakes I made.
At the same time, being raised as an only child by a single mom, boys were pretty much aliens. So to support and watch growing up from the boy side is a lot of fun and gives a feeling of balance in my life story. Plus being a "boy mom" is something I know, whereas being a "girl mom" equals new territory.
Either way I feel 100% ready for and open to whoever is hiccuping in my belly right now. When I was wishing on stars last spring, this little soul was listening and decided to answer our prayers by joining our family and for that I'm eternally thankful. Boy vs girl has zero importance in the big picture of our life.
That said I'll let you in on a secret. We both thought Max would be a boy, but this time our camps are divided. The mister thinks it's a boy and I totally think it's a girl.
[Baby shoes by Zara]